Saturday, September 25, 2010

KCL and KVL Sign Conventions

I was talking to Tom Ray yesterday about the course, and the topic of sign conventions in KCL and KVL came up.

In a nut shell, Tom and I follow the same convention on assigning the algebraic sign to the currents being summed in the KCL expression. We both use "+" signs for currents that are assumed to be entering a node.

However, we use the opposite convention when writing the KVL expressions. We will be covering KVL in class on Tuesday, so I will teach you the difference and then explain that the final answer doesn't change.

I was curious which texts use which convention. Here is a short summary of those texts I checked:

Texts that use Ray's preferred method:
  • Schaum's outlines
  • Irwin
  • Circuit Analysis Demystified by McMahon
Texts that use MacEachern's preferred method:
  • Boylstad
  • Electrical Circuit Theory and Technology by Bird
  • Concepts in Electrical Circuits by Naeem
  • Circuit Analysis Theory and Practice by Robbins
  • Circuits, Devices, and Systems by Smith
  • Analysis of Linear Circuits by Paul
  • Network Analysis by Bakshi

No comments:

Post a Comment